Tremendous Bowl LVIII is quick approaching. For a lot of Individuals, that may imply gathering with pals to look at the sport, get pleasure from some form of dip-based snacks, and gripe concerning the halftime present. However for intercourse employees and people who wish to patronize them, it can imply a better probability of getting nabbed by cops.
Beneath the guise of “stopping sex trafficking,” authorities are likely to ramp up prostitution stings round Tremendous Bowl time. The ostensible motive behind that is that enormous sporting occasions just like the Tremendous Bowl draw an inflow of traffickers and their victims to the locales internet hosting these occasions.
But nobody has managed to marshal proof of those hordes of traffickers allegedly descending on Tremendous Bowl cities. The perfect authorities can do is usually level to a spike in Tremendous Bowl weekend arrests of intercourse employees and their prospects—a spike simply defined by the truth that cops are making a concerted effort to catch folks providing to promote or pay for intercourse.
Need extra on intercourse, know-how, bodily autonomy, regulation, and on-line tradition? Subscribe to Intercourse & Tech from Cause and Elizabeth Nolan Brown.
The Tremendous Bowl intercourse trafficking fable is a sequel of types to an earlier concept—that home violence elevated across the Tremendous Bowl—for which there was additionally no proof. Each myths have served a political agenda.
On this case, the parable provides regulation enforcement license to do extra policing of intercourse employees and extra surveillance usually; lends itself to splashy campaigns by nonprofits that use these theatrics to garner donations; and bolsters an concept (intercourse trafficking is in every single place!) used to push tough-on-sex-work insurance policies.
Intercourse Staff Name To Cease the Stings
This yr’s Tremendous Bowl takes place at Allegiant Stadium in Las Vegas. Right now, Nevada intercourse employees and their allies will probably be gathering on the stadium to protest Tremendous Bowl intercourse stings and the myths that encourage them.
“Every year, the Super Bowl is used as an excuse to violently arrest sex workers under the guise of anti-trafficking raids,” notes a press launch concerning the protest, which is being organized by the Las Vegas Pink Umbrella Collective (LVRUC); the Intercourse Staff and Erotic Service Supplier Authorized, Academic and Analysis Venture (ESPLERP); and the Worldwide Intercourse Employee Basis for Artwork, Tradition, and Schooling (ISWFACE). This “Stop the Raids” coalition additionally held two days of workshops and community-building actions for intercourse employees over the previous weekend.
Police, media, and nonprofits “are all touting that false and misleading narrative that large sporting events cause forced labor in the sex trade and therefore warrants arresting us,” says Maxine Doogan of ESPLERP. “It’s clearly not good for us, or the sex trafficking victims or our clients to be burdened and punished with a prostitution arrests.”
Their objective “is to call attention to the public and the press that we’re not forced to work in the sex trade,” says Doogan. “It’s not OK to call us and our clients ‘sex-trafficking victims and traffickers.’ We’re workers, and our clients are our clients.”
Vegas Tremendous Bowl Provides Juice to a Fading Fantasy
A decade in the past, nearly all reporting on “Super Bowl sex trafficking” appeared to be wholly credulous of regulation enforcement’s narrative. From 2010 to 2016, 76 p.c of U.S. print media tales on the topic “propagated the ‘Super Bowl sex trafficking’ narrative,” in response to a 2019 paper printed within the Anti-Trafficking Overview. Again in 2014—when Maggie McNeill challenged this narrative in Cause—questioning it was a fairly lonely perch.
In recent times, extra retailers have been prepared to push again towards the official narrative, and items difficult it have appeared in such publications as Sports activities Illustrated, The Washington Publish, Slate, Vice, and The Atlantic.
However there’s nonetheless loads of life but on this outdated trope. Tales about Tremendous Bowl intercourse trafficking have been peppering Las Vegas media in current weeks.
Some teams pushing it are usually much less sure of their rhetoric than we have seen beforehand. However they nonetheless recommend that intercourse trafficking may improve across the Tremendous Bowl. “It really comes down to basic numbers—where there are people the possibility of crime and trafficking increases,” posted Agape Worldwide Missions (AIM) in January. “As the Super Bowl draws thousands of people to one location, this holds true.”
Thanks to @its_apenalty for having AG @AaronDFordNV at at the moment’s occasion to debate how the OAG and regulation enforcement are working to finish human trafficking in Nevada. pic.twitter.com/uOHeE4hH9s
— NV Legal professional Common (@NevadaAG) January 29, 2024
The truth that this yr’s Tremendous Bowl is occurring in Vegas provides teams one other angle for spreading discredited propaganda. Prostitution is not authorized in Las Vegas, however many assume it’s, because of the metropolis’s popularity and the truth that some counties in Nevada do enable authorized brothels.
“While the general link between human trafficking and Super Bowl host cities has become more speculative, Las Vegas may provide an exception to this conclusion,” AIM recommended, including that praying and giving to teams like AIM may assist fight this.
That is how a variety of “anti-trafficking efforts” go: a mission to lift “awareness” concerning the challenge that in flip encourages donations to the nonprofit “raising awareness.” Which could all be nicely and good if these teams had been making substantial strides towards serving to folks in abusive or exploitative conditions. However usually their “outreach” and “support” efforts quantity to little greater than further “awareness” elevating, and maybe handing out baggage of toiletries to folks police decide up in prostitution stings.
Campaigns just like the “It’s a Penalty” initiative working to unfold “awareness” about Tremendous Bowl intercourse trafficking aren’t operating shelters for victims or serving to them discover jobs or offering them with authorized help. No, the oldsters behind these initiatives spend their time and assets doing issues like passing out branded stickers and pens, making advertisements that includes skilled athletes, and inspiring folks to report their hunches to authorities.
Can You Spot a Intercourse Trafficker?
A Las Vegas nonprofit referred to as Indicators of HOPE “will be educating employees at Caesars Entertainment, MGM Resorts Wynn Resort properties” about tips on how to spot intercourse traffickers, reviews the Las Vegas Solar.
That is one other anti-trafficking trope—that eagle-eyed resort workers, airline staff, salon employees, and many others., can spot the “signs” of intercourse trafficking in the event that they’re simply “aware” sufficient. However the “signs” taught are usually utter nonsense: a mixture of sexist, racist, or classist stereotypes with issues broad sufficient to use to simply about anybody.
As an illustration, Indicators of HOPE chief Kimberly Small informed the Solar that the potential indicators of being a trafficking sufferer embrace lack of eye contact, extreme telephone use, or being too quiet.
Indicators of HOPE, It is a Penalty, and different teams urge folks to report something suspicious. It is an ethos prone to result in the harassment of any girls dressed provocatively or appearing flirtatiously.
Internet hosting spot-a-trafficker trainings might internet money or good P.R. for the teams that run them and the companies that make staff sit by means of them. However nobody appears to be providing proof that it’s serving to anybody catch traffickers or rescue their victims.
We now have, nevertheless, seen loads of instances the place it is led to folks getting reported for being in interracial {couples} or multiracial households. There’s additionally some proof that it results in elevated surveillance of girls usually.
For the 2024 Las Vegas Marketing campaign, we need to specific our gratitude to our unbelievable companions: @wynnlasvega@mgmresortsintl @caesarsentertainment @lasairport@raiders @airbnb @Hilton @southwestair
Carlson Household Basis @motel6 @ihghotels@ahlafoundation pic.twitter.com/MsfzCdNnVB— It is a Penalty (@its_apenalty) January 25, 2024
“Small added that people should even be aware of odd-looking situations, such as when a young child is being picked up by an older person, especially if the child seems unfamiliar with them,” reported the Solar. This manages to combine two trafficking myths into one: the concept there are giant swaths of precise youngsters within the U.S. being trafficked, and the concept trafficking—of adults or minors—is mostly completed by strangers.
“The truth about trafficking, particularly in the context of minors, is that it is often not perpetrated by strangers but by those within their own circles—friends, acquaintances and, tragically, family members,” writes ISWFACE’s Victoria McMahan Parra in The Nevada Impartial. “This pattern of exploitation, deeply rooted in a complex web of socioeconomic factors, reflects a systemic issue that goes beyond the simplistic narratives often peddled by sensationalist media and misinformed anti-trafficking campaigns.”
Why the Myths Persist
Media basically, and particularly native media, tends to be deferential to official narratives, particularly after they’re coming from cops. Their enterprise additionally thrives on lurid tales and warnings of hazard. So it is not shocking that apocryphal tales of Tremendous Bowl sex-crime spikes maintain resurfacing within the press.
Extra fascinating is why police are framing these efforts as intercourse trafficking or human trafficking stings within the first place. If it is simply an old school vice squad doing an old school prostitution sting, why all of the fanfare about traffickers? Why not simply inform the general public they’re out to catch consenting adults who combine cash with their intercourse?
Cause‘s J.D. Tuccille defined this gorgeous concisely again in 2016:
Opponents of economic intercourse discover themselves on the mistaken aspect of shifting public opinion, in order that they pull a little bit rhetorical sleight of hand….The implication of the “trafficking” terminology is that prostitutes are slaves—and so they’re being hustled off to a serious sporting occasion close to you.
Spending taxpayer cash and police time to ensure folks aren’t privately buying and selling intercourse for cash (or vice versa) is the form of factor many of us dislike. Stopping slavery sounds a lot extra noble—a trigger that everybody can get behind.
It additionally lets the federal authorities get entangled. Promoting and paying for intercourse aren’t federal crimes. However intercourse trafficking—outlined underneath federal regulation as industrial intercourse involving minors, drive, fraud, or coercion—is. That provides the FBI and the Division of Homeland Safety an excellent impetus to intervene (and if the stings simply occur to function an excellent cowl for all types of surveillance, so be it).
Framing prostitution stings as anti-human-trafficking initiatives additionally lets native regulation enforcement entry grant cash the feds give out for stopping trafficking. These grants don’t exist, theoretically, for merely stopping some man from paying a consenting grownup associate for intercourse.
After all, all of this goes on with out anybody having to really show that their work helps victims of violence or abuse.
What outcomes are “taxpayer-funded sting operations” towards “men and women who are engaged in work our government has deemed unacceptable,” writes Parra in her Nevada Impartial piece. She notes that even when police stings do uncover individuals who may use help or safety, they’re usually handled as criminals as a result of they fail to suit some excellent sufferer picture. “These stings, rather than addressing the nuanced and pervasive nature of trafficking, only perpetuate a cycle of criminalization and marginalization of already vulnerable groups.”
Right now’s protest in Vegas would be the third for Cease the Raids, which beforehand organized a protest in Phoenix round Tremendous Bowl time final yr and in addition a protest in Los Angeles final December.
The Los Angeles rally was held in protest of Metropolis Legal professional Hydee Feldstein Soto’s insurance policies “that criminalize and harass sex workers and their clients, all under the guise of rescuing sex trafficking victims,” in response to the group’s web site. “Feldstein-Soto has been weaponizing the archaic Red Light Abatement Act of 1913 to shut down motels where LA residents, particularly sex workers, had worked indoors safely.”